On
a trip to meet Gov. Rick Perry last month, the Indian ambassador
to the United States met with Satya Prabhakar at the Four Seasons
Hotel downtown. Ambassador Lalit Mansingh first heard of Prabhakar
and his Austin-based website, Sulekha.com, in January when the site,
little known outside the Indian community, crossed over in a big
way. A posting on the site about alleged pro-Pakistan bias on CNN
had led to an online petition of 55,000 names and a meeting with
executives at CNN's Atlanta headquarters. Mansingh was impressed.
He urged Sulekha.com's staff to make the site a window on India for
the rest of the world. "His main thing is, 'You guys are too
insular,'" says Prabhakar, who founded Sulekha.com in late 1998
with his wife, Sangeeta Kshettry. That should change. Sulekha,
which means, "good writing" in Sanskrit, the mother language
of Hindi started as a way to share the creative writings of a group
of friends. But it has grown into the world's largest online community.
This site now bubbles with selected essays on Indian identity in
the United States, news, discussions, movie reviews and even a database
of baby names. As Sulekha starts to find its global voice,
it chases a global business as well. It has 18 employees, more than
10,000 contributors and 7.5 million page views a month. In September
2000, a group of private New York investors put $3 million into the
site. Prabhakar and Kshettry would like to franchise the site's
model to other ethnic groups and interest groups. But first, Sulekha.com
must beat the challenge that faces dozens of content heavy sites:
how to turn popularity into profit. Some, such as Salon.com, have
gone public and struggled. Others, such as the "e-spirituality"
community Beliefnet.com, have received tens of millions in venture
investment but are far from profitability. Sulekha.com picked
the cheaper route. The site spends no money on advertising. But advertisers
such as Sprint Corp., AT&T Corp., Citigroup Inc.'s Citibank unit,
and Western Union Financial Services Inc., have found it anyway.
The site spends no money on content, but Penguin has published a
book of the site's best writing and wants to do more. The approach
seems to be working. Sulekha.com, which began with no business plan,
expects to be profitable this fall. Prabhakar won't disclose the
site's revenue, but he said until this year, expenses had been running
twice as high as sales. Quitting jobs to go to work Prabhakar
and Kshettry, both 38 and natives of India, have two young daughters
and no history of taking business risks. They are the first in their
families to go into business for themselves. To make Sulekha.com
work, they quit their jobs. In 1998, Kshettry left a $60,000 a year
job with the Texas Department of Insurance, and two years later,
Prabhakar quit his $115,000 a year job at SBC Communications Inc. "You're
always calculating the cost of going out on your own," Prabhakar
says, "But what the hell, you know. I felt reasonably qualified." Sulekha.com's
transformation from a creative writing site came in February 1999,
Prabhakar says, as he sat in a financial cryptography conference
on the Caribbean island of Anguilla, staring out a window at the
sea. He says he realized the huge volume of comments posted on the
site in the past week had to have a larger purpose to connect Indians
wherever they were in the world. "That was the huge motivating
factor," he says. Prabhakar picked up his legal pad and
wrote a 15-page plan for site development, brand positioning and
month-by-month content and traffic goals. "Suddenly I could
see Sulekha as a global community and not just some two bit ezine
on the net," he says. Soon after that, he quit his job. Still,
he was so nervous about telling his family about quitting that he
didn't tell them for months. He starts his business day at
3 a.m., trying to find ways to squeeze costs. Sulekha has 15 volunteer
editors helping the one paid employee who handles new content. Most
important, Prabhakar finds ways to promote Sulekha.com for free. A
year ago at a journalists' convention, Prabhakar met Hari Srinivas,
the US director for the Indian entertainment network B4U, which is
seen in about 80 countries. The two came up with a "Write
Angle" contest where writers would submit screenplay ideas to
Sulekha.com and the network would help produce the winning movie. "We
ran promos on our network for two or three months, 15 times a day,"
Srinivas says. Each one mentioned Sulekha.com for free. The
"Write Angle" project was what really made people, and
paying advertisers, recognize Sulekha.com. Prabhakar says, "We
were no longer just a web site; we were a player." Advertisers
find a market The growing attention could change the way US
advertisers treat the Indian market. About 70 percent of Sulekha.com's
users are in the United States. When the 2000 US census reported
that Indians are the fastest growing Asian group, with about 2 million
people, companies noticed. "We see the doors opening now,
" says Neeta Bhasin, who runs the New York based marketing company
ASB Communications, which targets the South Asian community for clients
such as Prudential Financial Inc. and Western Union. They are attracted
by the demographic: Indians in the United States have an average
household income of more than $60,000, Bhasin says, and about 90
percent of households have a computer. The 1990s tech boom,
fueled in part by Indians, helped change advertisers' outlook, Bhasin
says. It used to be, "They're the taxi drivers," she says.
"Now it's 'Oh, you must be a computer programmer'." Sulekha.com
is trying to convert that largely upscale spending power into a variety
of businesses: online event ticketing, targeting advertising, book
deals and the soon-to-be-launched e-publishing and event management
projects. But they want the commercialism to be low-key: In
a twist many companies wouldn't understand, Sulekha.com doesn't want
to offend its loyal users. "The biggest challenge we face today
is to keep Sulekha growing while retaining the intimacy, " Prabhakar
says. That means the site's workers take particular care to
help advertisers shape their message. "A Western Union ad was
turned into a game of Indian trivia," says Sulakshana Gopal,
Sulekha.com's manager of creative development and global marketing. "It's
been a very cautious approach," says Zafar Iqbal, a marketing
professor at DePaul University and a Sulekha.com user who has watched
ads slowly work their way onto the site. "Most savvy people
say, 'There's got to be money made here.' We understand that, but
it can't be blatant." Says Vijay Mahajan, a University
of Texas marketing professor who features Sulekha.com in a book on
marketing, "It's important that the community feels like it's
not being used." Community's the ticket One of the
site's established businesses is ticketing. Sulekha.com has become
the leading ticketer of Indian events in the United States, a business
that provides about 65 percent of the site's revenue. In a
recent showing of the Indian blockbuster "Kabhi Khushi Kabhie
Gham" in 16 US cities, Sulekha.com sold more than 11,000 tickets
at an average price of about $9, getting a commission of up to 6.95
percent, plus 50 cents of every transaction. Sulekha.com is
taking its name offline too. This year it will start investing in
and organizing some of the events for which it handles ticketing,
in return for a share of the profit. The site also has entered
into syndication deals with India's highest profile magazine, India
Today, in addition to deals with Yahoo India and MSN India. The publications
get Sulekha.com produced content, and Sulekha.com gets free promotion. The
site's splashiest offline move so far is its book, now titled "Black,
White and Various Shades of Brown". Last year, after Penguin
passed on publishing a selection of Sulekha.com writings, the site
spent $6000 to self-publish it. The 2400-plus copies sold out, Prabhakar
says. Based on those sales, Penguin changed its mind, says
V K Karthika, senior editor at Penguin India. Penguin printed 2000
copies for the Indian subcontinent. Nothing to get rich on, but enough
to start a relationship that both sides expect to produce more Sulekha.com
books. Two proposals are under discussion. "I really like
what Sulekha is doing finding young writers around the world,"
Karthika says. "It's like a bank for us as well." Penguin
has approached at least one Sulekha.com contributor about other books,
she says. Extending its publishing plans, Sulekha.com in August
will launch its Epress publishing business, making short books and
pamphlets written by contributors available online for a fee of a
few dollars apiece. The site is considering a few credit card-based
payment models. As Sulekha.com turns more of its contributors'
unpaid work into revenue, there is the chance that the community
could start to ask for a cut. Those featured in Sulekha.com's self-published
book, for example, got exposure, not money. "I don't know
how long that will last, but it seems to be working," says Iqbal,
the DePaul marketing professor. And if it doesn't last? Prabhakar,
who loves quotations, answers with wisdom from Warren Buffett and
the Bhagavad Gita in a single e-mail... From the Bhagavad Gita:
"Perform your duty equipoised, abandoning all attachment to
success or failure." From Buffet: "It is not that
I want money. It is the fun of making money and watching it grow." |